Jan 21, 2025 12:41

Cynicism, Isolation, and Suicidal Despair

Geoffrey Stekelenburg
Written by
Geoffrey Stekelenburg

I wish I could tell you there is an elixir to assuage the gnawing pangs of cynicism, a silver bullet for the bitter twinge of isolation, and a permanent bandage to the mortal wound of suicidal ideation. But rarely is life that simple. At 37, I’ve watched a few too many illusions break and nursed a few too many bruises — on my body, my heart and my soul. If I had a nickel for every “ Keep your chin up ,” well…I’d probably still roll my eyes at least some of the time. That’s cynicism for you. But cynicism, paradoxically, is also an ally in troubled times. Let’s tear apart the way those forces — cynicism and isolation and the specter of suicide — twist in a deadly waltz. And let’s also discuss what we might do about it, together.

The Paradox of Cynicism

Crazy as it sounds, cynicism can be like the world’s meanest bouncer. It puts a barrier — hardened skepticism — between you and the hope of another letdown. The reasoning is something like: If I anticipate this bad thing, I won’t get sucker-punched by it later. It’s a warped defense mechanism, a shield made from all those rejections when life said, “ Nope ,” and you replied, “ I stop giving a fuck .”

But cynicism’s protective armor often becomes a prison cell, where hope is sentenced to isolation. In shielding ourselves from the chance of more heartbreak, we enclose ourselves from the possibility of joy, comfort and genuine connection. You’ll be safer from dashed expectations, sure, but you’ll end up a recluse in your own mind, looking out through bars you yourself built.

We can trace a line to Greek Cynics (such as Diogenes) who believed in simple living and telling unpleasant truths. And the trouble comes when “ speaking blunt truths ” becomes an unending chain of negativity. Consider: Is your cynicism what you truly believe, or is it your bruised psyche attempting to self-medicate in sarcasm and distrust?

Isolation: Like a Hammering Echo Chamber

People confuse solitude with loneliness. Aloneness can be balm — as in a long, meditative walk alone through the woods. Isolation, by contrast, is an unbearable situation in which you feel estranged from nurturing human interaction. You’re not electing to be alone; it’s pressed into the fabric of your life.

Negative thoughts grow in isolation. Stuck inside your own head, you might think you’re the only one weathering these emotional storms. That’s the big lie. Most people are so caught up in the storms of their own lives that they don’t notice yours, which makes it seem all the more true that you’re up against the universe all alone. Your cynicism expands, your bitterness deepens, and it feels futile to reach for, or trust in, anyone.

When the world has gone all “ Lost in Space ,” it’s simpler to stand behind plenty of locked doors. But what begins as a self-protective strategy can devolve into a downward spiral of disconnection. We forfeit the faith that anyone will understand, much less truly care.

When the End is Nigh

If you’ve woken in the morning with an empty pit that just won’t leave your stomach, you’ll understand when I say suicidal thoughts don’t schedule their arrival via email. They sneak in unnoticed, usually at those silenced moments when you’ve grown tired of being tired, and that cynic who’s convinced you that there’s one way out gets to chime in.

And why cynicism and isolation make it worse…

Cynicism will tell you that life is inherently meaningless or rigged against you.

Isolation convinces you that nobody cares, or even if they do, they can’t possibly understand your agony.

That’s a recipe for despair. In those dark days, you might wonder what the hell you’re even doing here. The emotional calculus of heartbreak and exhaustion may seem like it comes up to only one, irreversible answer.

This question vexed thinkers like Camus, who described suicide as “ the only serious philosophical problem .” The conundrum: If we agree that life is absurd, do we surrender to that absurdity, or do we rise up against it? Rebellion, in this way, is to live — to say “ yes ” to fraying relationships, to challenges that might be as trying as they are lovely.

Where Peer Support Fits In

I’ve walked the long road of meeting therapists, coaches, fellow pilgrims, and sometimes perfect strangers who had big ears. Genuine peer support is gold because it turns cynicism on its head. All of a sudden you are in a room with people who understand it. And not because they studied it from textbooks, but because they lived it.

Peer support is not the familiar slogans or fortune-cookie pep talks. It’s about someone saying, “ I’ve been there ,” or, “ I see you, for real .” It’s about building hollows of comprehension in a world that can seem like a maze.

Cynicism may roll its eyes at the notion of hope, but the second you see someone else’s bravery or stick-to-it-tiveness it resonates somewhere deep.

The Parting of the Ways

I’m not trying to sell you sunshine in a jar. Life can be grimy, cruel and downright baffling. But there’s a kind of rebellious beauty in confronting it anyway, as battered as we may be. While cynicism can help protect us, isolation can feel like a refuge and suicide can even seem like a way out—peer support is where these delusions can be tempered. Once you open up to someone who’s traveled a similarly dark road, you understand you’re not alone in the darkness.

Existence with a pervasive “ why bother? ” sensación is exhausting, I know. But when I discovered that people who were just as bruised were willing to help pick one another up in little ways, my cynicism began to soften. It’s not that I’m cured. Far from it. It’s that I’ve learned there’s a texture to human connection, that cynicism can be reined in, isolation eased and that the swirling specter of suicide can be, step by step, pushed back.

So yes, hold onto your cynicism if you need it; it’s a wily companion in small doses. But as you do, hold on to your curiosity, your willingness to reach out, and your ability to question your own darkest assumptions. Sure, this life is absurd, but it’s the only show in town. If we are going to stand upon it, we might as well do that hand in hand with those who understand.